Homeownership can be complicated, but we also think it’s one of the most rewarding ventures out there. In our series Ask an Edina Realty Lawyer, we are hoping to demystify some of the trickier aspects of buying, selling and owning a home.
In this edition, one of our lawyers discusses the legality around sellers having hidden cameras or other recording devices on while a potential buyer tours your property.
Dear Edina Realty Legal,
My home is currently listed for sale. I have a couple of hidden cameras for security purposes, but have been told that it is illegal for me to have the cameras on when I have open houses or showings. Is that true?
Well, that’s partly true and partly not. When it comes to hidden cameras and other recording devices, each state has its own rules. For the purposes of this article, we’ll just focus on those rules applicable to Edina Realty’s primary areas of Minnesota and Wisconsin.
In Minnesota and Wisconsin (and many other states) it’s important to distinguish between the recording of video only and the capturing of audio of conversations.
As a general rule, you are allowed to videotape (even secretly) in your own home.
There are a number of legitimate reasons a homeowner may want to install a hidden camera in their home. A camera could capture video evidence in case of a burglary. Or the homeowner might want to be able to keep an eye on their kids or pets. Keep in mind:
- For the most part, it is perfectly legal to have a camera taking video of what occurs within your home.
- This is true even if the camera is capturing video of someone without their knowledge.
- One big caveat to that general rule is that you are not permitted to place a camera with the intention or likelihood of capturing a person taking their clothes off — for example, in a bathroom.
It’s a different story when it comes to capturing audio without the speaker’s knowledge or consent.
While it is generally permissible to record video, state regulations treat the recording of audio differently.
- In Minnesota and Wisconsin, it is against the law to use electronic means to intercept an oral communication when it is made with the reasonable expectation that it remain private. These laws are generally focused on wiretapping, but are broader than that. An oral communication can be a conversation between two or more people.
- A conversation between prospective buyers of your home and their agents would appear to fall into the definition of an oral communication.
- There is an exception to the law that allows a party to a conversation to secretly record that conversation. But you are not a party to the conversations between potential buyers and their agents.
So, in short, it’s generally ok to have a video camera in your home. However, if you’re going to have showings and open houses, you should adjust your camera settings to not record the audio.
The Edina Realty legal department serves as in-house counsel for Edina Realty and does not represent private clients. This article is not intended to provide legal advice.
